|
|
Post by greenchristian on Nov 15, 2019 19:55:40 GMT
Because there are insufficient votes left between the remaining "live" candidates to overhaul her even if they all transferred to the same candidate. Note the pile of non-transferred votes, 110 of them after stage 3, they're not going anywhere else, so she has >50% of the votes identifiable with a candidate. In previous counts in Scotland, they have insisted upon reaching the quota, even to the extent of distributing the next preferences of the last eliminated candidate. It seems they have now got the message, at least in Highland. The message being to provide less psephological data from their counts? Not exactly a good message, is it? |
|
|
|
Post by andrew111 on Nov 15, 2019 21:59:06 GMT
In previous counts in Scotland, they have insisted upon reaching the quota, even to the extent of distributing the next preferences of the last eliminated candidate. It seems they have now got the message, at least in Highland. The message being to provide less psephological data from their counts? Not exactly a good message, is it? CAMOPED That is my newly formed Campaign for More Psephological Data |
|
Toylyyev
Mebyon Kernow
CJ Fox avatar
Posts: 1,067 
|
Post by Toylyyev on Nov 20, 2019 23:13:00 GMT
Transfers for the Fife Dunfermline Central and Rosyth wards:
I II III IV V VI
Derek Glen SNP 1526 2 7% 100 42% 133 20% 37 3% 499 28% 2297
Aude Boubaker-Calder LibDem 1050 3 11% 64 27% 226 34% 453 38% 1796
Chloe Dodds C 1142 8 29% 6 3% 46 7% 1202
Michael Boyd Lab 621 3 11% 32 14% 656
Fiona McOwan Green 235 2 7$ 237
Keith Chamberlain Libt 28
not transferable 10 36% 35 15% 251 38% 712 59% 1297 72% 2305
I II III IV V VI
Sharon Green-Wilson SNP 1347 - 59 44% 23 14% 57 20% 153 26% 1639
Margaret Fairgrieve C 768 3 19% 3 2% 48 29% 63 22% 91 15% 976
Billy Pollock Lab 480 - 18 13% 28 17% 65 22% 591
Jill Blair LibDem 249 1 6% 25 19% 16 10% 291
Alastair MacIntyre Ind 157 5 31% 6 4% 168
Craig McCutcheon Green 132 3 19% 135
Calum Paul Libt 16
not transferable 4 25% 24 18% 53 32% 106 36% 347 59% 534
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Fife_Council_election#By-elections_since_2017 ยน [1] Download problem at Fife council page: "The page you are looking for cannot be found" Edit (11/12): The Fife site works now for me. And the pdf has 6 transfer votes for the Conservative candidate in Dunfermline Central instead of the 0 displayed in the wikipedia link at the moment of writing for the third stage of Dunfermline Central. And 46 instead of 52 at stage 4. The Green in Rosyth has 3 instead of 1 at stage 1. publications.fifedirect.org.uk/c64_CandidateVotesPerStage_Report_Ward_3_-_Dunfermline_Central_15112019_000600.pdfpublications.fifedirect.org.uk/c64_CandidateVotesPerStage_Report_Ward_5_-_Rosyth_15112019_001725.pdf |
|
|
|
Post by minionofmidas on Dec 11, 2019 13:14:13 GMT
In previous counts in Scotland, they have insisted upon reaching the quota, even to the extent of distributing the next preferences of the last eliminated candidate. It seems they have now got the message, at least in Highland. I know, I've seen it. case in point
Transfers for the Fife Dunfermline Central and Rosyth wards:
I II III IV V VI
Derek Glen SNP 1526 2 7% 100 42% 133 20% 37 3% 499 28% 2297
Aude Boubaker-Calder LibDem 1050 3 11% 64 27% 226 34% 453 38% 1796
Chloe Dodds C 1142 8 29% - 52 8% 1202
Michael Boyd Lab 621 3 11% 32 14% 656
Fiona McOwan Green 235 2 7$ 237
Keith Chamberlain Libt 28
not transferable 10 36% 41 17% 245 37% 712 59% 1297 72%
(actually, the last elimination in the other Fife count is also just about unnecessary, but at least that provided meaningful psephological data!) |
|
