|
Post by greenhert on Jun 21, 2023 18:31:20 GMT
Certain parliamentary by-elections in recent history could have easily been avoided, and in some cases the consequences would have been very significant.
The Kensington & Chelsea by-election of 1999, for example, most notable for a comeback by Michael Portillo, would likely not have occurred if Nicholas Scott (Conservative MP for Paddington South from 1966 to February 1974 and Chelsea from October 1974 to 1997) had behaved more responsibly and kept his alcohol problem under control, since he would then have been reselected meaning that Alan Clark would not have been selected for Kensington & Chelsea, and likely not have returned to Parliament at all for that matter. It would also mean that said Michael Portillo would likely not have returned to Parliament in time to be a contender in the Conservative Party's leadership contest of 2001, where he finished 3rd by only 1 vote in the penultimate round (and he led in the first 2 rounds). What impact would this have had?
If Harold Wilson had not nominated Fred Peart to the peerage in 1976, but instead asked for him to simply retire in 1979 and then get a peerage via James Callaghan's Dissolution Honours instead, the Workington by-election of 1976 would not have occurred meaning that the VONC of 1979 could have been avoided.
What are your thoughts?
|
|
|
Post by uthacalthing on Jun 21, 2023 22:25:25 GMT
Superb thread.
BTW. if Alex Salmond had not resigned his seat in the Scottish Parliament in 2001, creating a by-election, then Boogieeck would have contested the Westminster seat against Stewart Stevenson
It would have made a huge difference to history, but not to Boogieeck
|
|
|
Post by michaelarden on Jun 22, 2023 18:47:14 GMT
If Chris Huhne hadn't asked his missus to take the points he wouldn't have done time and presumably stayed in the cabinet when his affair was revealed.
Two consequences - Davey would have been unlikely to make the cabinet and remained as post office minister. And the Lib Dems wouldn't have had the false hope of thinking they could defy political gravity and come out with 30+ seats and continue the coalition.
|
|
stb12
Top Poster
Posts: 8,380
|
Post by stb12 on Jun 22, 2023 23:23:38 GMT
With Winnie Ewing's death the 1967 Hamilton by-election is an interesting one for this thread in considering if it would have changed the course of Scottish nationalism at all
According to wikipedia the incumbent Tom Fraser simply resigned to take another job so therefore it could have been avoided
|
|
|
Post by Davıd Boothroyd on Jun 22, 2023 23:45:27 GMT
With Winnie Ewing's death the 1967 Hamilton by-election is an interesting one for this thread in considering if it would have changed the course of Scottish nationalism at all According to wikipedia the incumbent Tom Fraser simply resigned to take another job so therefore it could have been avoided There was an element of 'cashing in'. Fraser was a Gaitskellite who had been in Wilson's first cabinet because Wilson was obliged to include him; he went out at the first big reshuffle (replaced by Barbara Castle who was a firm Wilsonite). In 1967 he went off to be chairman of the North of Scotland Hydroelectric Board, exchanging the MP's salary of £3,250 for a Quango salary of £9,750.
|
|