Post by islington on Jun 28, 2020 16:27:08 GMT
Let me respond quickly so I can be the first to say that that is miles better than my plan.
I'd go for Carpenders Park as the Three Rivers ward in Watford.
The real advantage of taking Bushey N as the ward to add to Watford is that it comprises Bushey Hall (physically part of the built-up area of Watford/Oxhey) and Bushey Mill, but is separated by green belt from Bushey proper. If you take any of the Three Rivers wards you unavoidably divide either South Oxhey (split between the three Watford Rural parish wards) or the core of Abbots Langley itself (split between the three Abbots Langley parish wards). It does mean that Hertsmere is no longer co-terminous with the district - but on the other hand Three Rivers is now united in a single seat. It avoids the awkward link of St Stephens in SW Herts and it means you can add St Albans to the list of almost-unchanged seats. Plus there is no imperative to retain the link between Hitchin & Harpenden (unlike say Welwyn-Hatfield or Hertford & Stortford).
It also means all the seats in Beds are retained essentially intact. Under the Dunstable & Berkhamstead option, the existing SW Beds and existing mid-Beds seats have to be significantly altered as they shuffle northwards; whereas under this option, each of them (as well as NE Beds) simply loses sufficient electors to fall within quota (apart from changes to fit with new ward boundaries).
Thanks. I think on balance I still prefer pepperminttea's scheme, but I agree that your version is also much better than my plan.
On a minor point, Stanstead Abbots shouldn't be separated from Gt Amwell so I'd put it in Broxbourne in exchange for Hertford Rural S, which looks much more comfortable in a seat with Hertford.
I also note that you have two seats straddling the boundary between C Beds and Bedford. Would it not be possible to adjust this so that this boundary is crossed only once?
I'm intrigued by the small segment of west Essex showing on your map. Have you done the whole county? I managed to treat it separately, with no cross-border seats, but I found it a real struggle to cram in 19 seats. Part of the price I ended up paying was an Epping & Harlow seat (the two Epping town wards, Broadley Common and the whole borough of Harlow).