|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 10, 2016 22:53:13 GMT
You're not going to work your way through the fucking alphabet, are you? Please don't block me, they shall all be full in 6 Hours
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 10, 2016 23:00:22 GMT
You're not going to work your way through the fucking alphabet, are you? Looks rather like what in the US is known as "suicide by cop".
|
|
|
Post by Davıd Boothroyd on Oct 10, 2016 23:25:08 GMT
You're not going to work your way through the fucking alphabet, are you? Please don't block me, they shall all be full in 6 Hours You really aren't learning much from your previous blocks.
|
|
|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 10, 2016 23:26:03 GMT
Please don't block me, they shall all be full in 6 Hours You really aren't learning much from your previous blocks. Well, look at my progress at filling in the posts
|
|
|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 11, 2016 0:12:49 GMT
WALES Ynys Mon 44381 Arfon 42645 Dwyfor Meirionnydd 43283 Aberconwy 44153 Colwyn 46203 Rhuddlan 45178 Delyn 43749 Deeside 43834 Alyn 46675 Wrexham 44694 Maelor 44578 Glyndŵr 43227 Ceredigion 44203 Radnor & Montgomery 45892 Brecknock & Abergavenny 45930 Monmouth 44920 Newport East 43424 Newport West 42673 Cwmbran 43922 Torfaen 46879 Blaenau Gwent 45389 Islwyn 43843 Caerphilly 44701 Rhymney 42974 Merthyr Tydfil 43737 Cynon Valley 45368 Rhondda 42664 Taff 43555 Cardiff West 46045 Cardiff North 44565 Cardiff East 43899 Cardiff Central 43151 Cardiff South 44498 Barry 45030 Vale of Glamorgan 45106 Ely 44588 Bridgend 45661 Ogwr 45816 Afan 45138 Neath 43448 Swansea East 42558 Swansea Central 45214 Swansea West 46851 Lliw 46650 Llanelli 43475 Dinefwr 45556 Carmarthen 44856 Pembroke 42957 Preseli 44105
|
|
|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 11, 2016 0:12:59 GMT
NORTHERN IRELAND County Armagh Newry 44502 Armagh 44465 Craigavon 46189 County Fermanagh Fermanagh 44892 Counties Tyrone, Derry, Antrim Dungannon 45178 Cookstown 43196 Omagh & Strabane 45707 Derry West 44622 Derry East & Dungiven 43918 Limavady & Magherafelt 42711 Coleraine 43468 Ballymena 43805 Ballycastle & Larne 44391 Carrickfergus 42941 Newtownabbey 43866 Antrim 43496 Lisburn 43912 Belfast Dunmurry 44020 Belfast Falls 42788 Belfast Fortwilliam 44471 County Down Belfast Castlereagh 43717 Dundonald 45606 Bangor 45014 Newtonards 45662 Downpatrick & Comber 45381 Carryduff 45550 Banbridge 42998 Newcastle, Warrenpoint & Kilkeel 46903
|
|
|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 11, 2016 0:13:12 GMT
LONDON
|
|
|
Post by johnloony on Oct 11, 2016 0:37:55 GMT
Please don't block me, they shall all be full in 6 Hours You really aren't learning much from your previous blocks. Give the lad a chance. At least he's in a different time zone, so he's working through everything while ordinary people are asleep (he has neglected to realise that we here on this forum are not exactly ordinary, but anyway). The maps will soon be complete and I will be curious to see what South London looks like. I think we should applaud the fact that a child has the intelligence and dedication to work out all this, and finish all 1000 seats, where most would get bored and give up after about 50. Will notional results (votes for each party) be included in the final version?
|
|
|
Post by johnloony on Oct 11, 2016 0:43:05 GMT
You really aren't learning much from your previous blocks. Well, look at my progress at filling in the posts Yes indeed. Still, it would be a better idea to put all the information you have (including the numbers and the maps) in the comments as you go along, without typing in the titles in empty messages beforehand. In other words, plan your work as if it were not possible to "edit" a comment after you've written it. The "edit" thing should really only be used for correcting typographical errors or clarifying minor points, rather than for adding in lots of extra information hours later.
|
|
|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 11, 2016 1:14:41 GMT
You really aren't learning much from your previous blocks. Give the lad a chance. At least he's in a different time zone, so he's working through everything while ordinary people are asleep (he has neglected to realise that we here on this forum are not exactly ordinary, but anyway). The maps will soon be complete and I will be curious to see what South London looks like. I think we should applaud the fact that a child has the intelligence and dedication to work out all this, and finish all 1000 seats, where most would get bored and give up after about 50. Will notional results (votes for each party) be included in the final version? Notionals: NO London : I don't know if I will get around to it, just as I haven't got around to it in the 650 seats thread, along with Scotland, West Midlands, Greater Manchester, Merseyside
|
|
|
Post by finsobruce on Oct 11, 2016 10:14:23 GMT
You're not going to work your way through the fucking alphabet, are you? Looks rather like what in the US is known as "suicide by cop". "online immolation by spam"
|
|
The Bishop
Labour
Down With Factionalism!
Posts: 36,773
Member is Online
|
Post by The Bishop on Oct 11, 2016 10:16:07 GMT
Except that he had filled most of them in by the time most of us logged in this morning, so maybe deserves the benefit of the doubt on this occasion. As you like to ask others, ASV - going to do the rest tonight?
|
|
|
Post by Pete Whitehead on Oct 11, 2016 10:20:59 GMT
It's his thread - nobody else is uunder any obligation to engage with it. It's not like 'spamming' other threads such as my Lander threads or all the US election ones. I would say that it is probably best not to dump a massive load of posts in one night simply because most people will not be bothered to read through 3 new pages of posts and digest all the maps. better to do one county a night and then allow for discussion of those by anyone interested
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 11, 2016 10:36:31 GMT
It's his thread - nobody else is uunder any obligation to engage with it. It's not like 'spamming' other threads such as my Lander threads or all the US election ones. I would say that it is probably best not to dump a massive load of posts in one night simply because most people will not be bothered to read through 3 new pages of posts and digest all the maps. better to do one county a night and then allow for discussion of those by anyone interested Yes, that would be a better way to proceed. The reason that some people - including me - get exasperated is that they tend to follow what is going on by checking "Recent Posts" rather than specific threads. We don't like wading through pages of content-free posts by ASV.
|
|
|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 11, 2016 10:38:56 GMT
Except that he had filled most of them in by the time most of us logged in this morning, so maybe deserves the benefit of the doubt on this occasion. As you like to ask others, ASV - going to do the rest tonight? ;) I have filled in all that I have previously mapped, this is how I will do it in the Future, map almost all, upload in 1 day so placeholders are only existing overnight. Well, some may never be finished, (look at my 650 seats thread) but most should be finished over the next few days
|
|
|
Post by greenhert on Oct 11, 2016 10:41:35 GMT
This fantasy review would be useful if we had regional assemblies in England using AMS, incidentally. The Welsh Assembly's single member constituencies should be smaller than their Westminster equivalents.
|
|
|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 11, 2016 10:48:58 GMT
I am sad that I have so many comments here, but almost none on my 650 seat thread, so could some people read through my 650 seat thread, which is altogether more important and realistic given that it is the current number of seats in Westminster and I would like to see some peoples opinions and ideas as it is interesting in some areas the difference between old and new boundaries
|
|
|
Post by Pete Whitehead on Oct 11, 2016 10:53:48 GMT
HERTFORDSHIRE Hitchin 44962 Letchworth 45502 Stevenage 42529 Royston & Ware 46342 Bishop's Stortford 43188 Hertford & Hoddesdon 44092 Cheshunt 45929 Welwyn 43105 Hatfield 44280 Borehamwood & Potters Bar 43987 Bushey 46142 Watford 42953 Rickmansworth 46146 Abbots Langley 43811 St Albans 45544 Harpenden 42609 Hemel Hempstead 44121 Berkhamsted & Tring 45988 Well I did specifically mention in an earlier discussion about this model that Hertfordshire is difficult with this number of seats as while St Albans city is the perfect size, the other large towns are not and you have to hive off wards. That being said, nothing is going to be ideal but I think the way you've done that particularly in relation to Watford and your Bushey seat. I don't know if you've gone for any tight 5% or 10% threshold here which is limiting your room for maneuver but I've chosen not to as there is no need when doing fantasy boundaries and within reason I prefer to give more regard to natural communities than equal electorates. So here's my alternative suggestion
|
|
|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 11, 2016 10:56:17 GMT
HERTFORDSHIRE Hitchin 44962 Letchworth 45502 Stevenage 42529 Royston & Ware 46342 Bishop's Stortford 43188 Hertford & Hoddesdon 44092 Cheshunt 45929 Welwyn 43105 Hatfield 44280 Borehamwood & Potters Bar 43987 Bushey 46142 Watford 42953 Rickmansworth 46146 Abbots Langley 43811 St Albans 45544 Harpenden 42609 Hemel Hempstead 44121 Berkhamsted & Tring 45988 Well I did specifically mention in an earlier discussion about this model that Hertfordshire is difficult with this number of seats as while St Albans city is the perfect size, the other large towns are not and you have to hive off wards. That being said, nothing is going to be ideal but I think the way you've done that particularly in relation to Watford and your Bushey seat. I don't know if you've gone for any tight 5% or 10% threshold here which is limiting your room for maneuver but I've chosen not to as there is no need when doing fantasy boundaries and within reason I prefer to give more regard to natural communities than equal electorates. So here's my alternative suggestion Check at the top of the thread, 5% variance leading to limits of 42504 to 46978 meaning that Berkhampsted & Tring 39980, Royston & Braughing 41798, Watford 41308 are under quota Bishops Stortford & Ware at 50916, Stevenage 47180 are over quota.
|
|
|
Post by AustralianSwingVoter on Oct 11, 2016 11:02:41 GMT
HERTFORDSHIRE Hitchin 44962 Letchworth 45502 Stevenage 42529 Royston & Ware 46342 Bishop's Stortford 43188 Hertford & Hoddesdon 44092 Cheshunt 45929 Welwyn 43105 Hatfield 44280 Borehamwood & Potters Bar 43987 Bushey 46142 Watford 42953 Rickmansworth 46146 Abbots Langley 43811 St Albans 45544 Harpenden 42609 Hemel Hempstead 44121 Berkhamsted & Tring 45988 Well I did specifically mention in an earlier discussion about this model that Hertfordshire is difficult with this number of seats as while St Albans city is the perfect size, the other large towns are not and you have to hive off wards. That being said, nothing is going to be ideal but I think the way you've done that particularly in relation to Watford and your Bushey seat. I don't know if you've gone for any tight 5% or 10% threshold here which is limiting your room for maneuver but I've chosen not to as there is no need when doing fantasy boundaries and within reason I prefer to give more regard to natural communities than equal electorates. So here's my alternative suggestion oh and pete, would you be so kind as to post your hertfordshire 650 seat plan on the 650 seat thread?
|
|